Skip to main content

Android Looper and Toast from WorkerThread

Have you ever tried to launch Android Toast message from worker thread? Probably you are wondering why the heck it is giving this error-

java.lang.RuntimeException: Can't create handler inside thread that has not called Looper.prepare()

In this article we are going to explore reason behind the above exception and try to understand how Looper works in Android. At the end, I am going to explain one approach to run Toast from a worker thread, but before that we need to understand how Looper works. If you already know in/out of Looper, you can skip below section and directly move to the solution part.

Looper is a very basic wrapper class which attach a MessageQueue to a Thread and manage this queue. MessageQueue is a structure to sequentialize simultaneous processing requests of a Thread.  In Android, message/request processing classes like Handler uses Looper to manage their respective MessageQueue.
Looper = Thread + MessageQueue

Android Looper Life Cycle:


As you can see in the above figure, Looper Life cycle starts when we call prepare(), this static method creates instance of Looper class and store this in a ThreadLocal variable. Below code snippet from Looper source.

private static void prepare(boolean quitAllowed) {
    if (sThreadLocal.get() != null) {
        throw new RuntimeException("Only one Looper may be created per thread");
    }
    sThreadLocal.set(new Looper(quitAllowed));
}

private Looper(boolean quitAllowed) {
    mQueue = new MessageQueue(quitAllowed);
    mRun = true;
    mThread = Thread.currentThread();
}

Once Looper instance is created we have to call loop() which starts an infinite Loop and process requests accumulated in the Message Queue. Below code from Looper.java

public static void loop() {

// Looper instance and Thread verification

    final MessageQueue queue = me.mQueue;

    for (;;) {
        Message msg = queue.next(); // might block
        if (msg == null) {
            // No message indicates that the message queue is quitting.
            return;
        }
        // Process Messages
    }
}

Due to above Infinite Loop, Looper blocks the current Thread execution until we call Quit. To get a hook to know when Looper is done with Message processing or when Message Queue is empty, we need to register MessageQueue.IdleHandler listener to the MessageQueue associated to the respective Looper. This can be achieved as-

// Prepare looper
Looper.prepare();
                 
// Register Queue listener hook
MessageQueue queue = Looper.myQueue();
queue.addIdleHandler(new IdleHandler() {
@Override
     public boolean queueIdle() {
          // TODO Auto-generated method stub
          return false;
     }
});
                 
// Start looping Message Queue
Looper.loop();

Running Toast from Worker Thread
Now, lets explain how we can run Toast in a thread other than UI or Main Thread. If we look inside of Toast.java, when we call makeText() internally it initialize Handler on the Calling thread. So, if the calling thread has not yet been attached to a MessageQueue Toast fails to create its instance. The only way to attach MessageQueue to a Thread is to use Looper, as a result Toast.java throws below exception-

java.lang.RuntimeException: Can't create handler inside thread that has not called Looper.prepare()

Toast.java -> Toast.TN.java -> Handler.java

public Toast(Context context) {
        mContext = context;
        mTN = new TN();
        mTN.mY = context.getResources().getDimensionPixelSize(
                com.android.internal.R.dimen.toast_y_offset);
}

public Handler() {
        // .......
        mLooper = Looper.myLooper();
        if (mLooper == null) {
            throw new RuntimeException(
                "Can't create handler inside thread that has not called Looper.prepare()");
        }
        mQueue = mLooper.mQueue;
        mCallback = null;
}

So, I hope we now understand the real meaning of this famous error message. Lets now try an alternate approach to execute Toast in a separate Thread.

We need to initialize Looper and attach MessageQueue to our calling Thread prior to launch Toast. When we call show() method of Toast, it sends Handler message to process display logic of Toast, then it waits for defined time (LONG/SHORT) and then calls hide() which again sends Handler message to remove Toast View. Thus Looper associated to Toast is requesting for MessageQueue twice, so we'll keep a counter to track number of MessageQueue requests and when it is 2, we'll quit the Looper. It is really important to quit the Looper, as if we don't do so, it will block all further operations, since Looper.loop() is a blocking call.

Here is the code snippet to run Toast in a separate Thread-

public void aboutLooper() {
 Thread th = new Thread() {
      public void run() {
          System.out.println("Start Looper...");
          // Prepare looper
          Looper.prepare();

          // Register Queue listener hook
          MessageQueue queue = Looper.myQueue();
          queue.addIdleHandler(new IdleHandler() {
               int mReqCount = 0;

               @Override
               public boolean queueIdle() {
                   if (++mReqCount == 2) {
                        // Quit looper
                        Looper.myLooper().quit();
                        return false;
                   } else
                        return true;
               }
          });

          // Show Toast- will be called when Looper.loop() starts
          Toast.makeText(MainActivity.this, "Hey there!!",
                   Toast.LENGTH_LONG).show();
          // Start looping Message Queue- Blocking call
          Looper.loop();
          System.out.println("It appears after Looper.myLooper().quit()");
      }
 };
 th.start();
}

Comments

  1. Don't understand the mReqCount part. Can you please explain?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Without delving into the details, I just recall that the docs. (http://developer.android.com/guide/components/processes-and-threads.html) explicitly say: "Do not access the Android UI toolkit from outside the UI thread". You should have mentioned that in the article, and explain how that is relevant or irrelevant to your scenario. Cheers!

    ReplyDelete
  3. This method can occasionally end the thread before the end toast message has been processed because the queueIdle() method will be called when a message is received even if the message is not scheduled to be processed yet.

    A more elegant and working solution can be found here: http://stackoverflow.com/questions/18280012/how-to-replace-the-system-out-with-toasts-inside-a-thread/18280318#18280318

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hey, I had a great time reading your website. Do you have an email address that I can contact you on? Thank you and hope to hear from you soon.

    Regards,

    Joel
    JHouston791 gmail.com

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Android Parcelable Example

Few days back I had a requirement to send a ArrayList of my Custom Class Objects through Android Intent , I guess most of you also find this requirement now and then. I never thought it can be that tricky. There are built in functions in Intent to send ArrayList of primitive objects e.g. String, Integer, but when it comes to Custom Data Handling Objects, BOOM … you need to take that extra pain! Android has defined a new light weight IPC ( Inter Process Communication ) data structure called Parcel , where you can flatten your objects in byte stream, same as J2SDK’s Serialization concept. So let’s come back to my original requirement, I had a Data Handling class, which groups together a set of information- public class ParcelData {       int id;       String name;       String desc;       String[] cities = {"suwon", "delhi"}; } I want an ArrayList<ParcelData> of Data Handling objec...

Call Control in Android

This tutorial is for those who want to control Phone Call in Android OS. Programmatic approach to Accept or Reject call without user intervention. Kindly note, this approach uses Java Reflection to call methods of an internal class of Android Telephony Framework and might not work with all versions of Android OS. The core concept has been explained in this Android open code . 1st thing 1st, Give the permission . You need to define 3 User Permissions to handle call related functionality- android.permission.READ_PHONE_STATE android.permission.MODIFY_PHONE_STATE (For answerRingingCall() method) android.permission.CALL_PHONE (For endCall() method) Define a Receiver... Create a Receiver which accepts broadcasts with intent action android.intent.action.PHONE_STATE, define following in the Manifest- [receiver android:name=".PhoneCall"]         [intent-filter]             [action android:name="android.in...

Overlay on Android Layout

This will help you to create custom Layout and add Overlay on a LinearLayout. The concept can be reused on other Layout classes i.e. RelativeLayout, FrameLayout etc. I have added a popup Selection Palette, containing "Map Pin" and "List" icons. You can minimize the popup by clicking on the section in Green on the left side bottom corner of the screen.   How can I do that- You need to follow 4 steps- 1. Override LinearLayout Create a Class MyLinearLayout.java which should overwrite LinearLayout 2. Drawing You need to overwrite dispatchDraw (Canvas canvas) method. It gives control to the whole screen. Make sure you set android:layout_height="fill_parent" for the associated layout definition in XML. You can draw anything and anywhere on the canvas. dispatchDraw (Canvas canvas) gets called only after underlying views are drawn, so whatever you draw comes in the foreground.   3. Event Handling You need to overwrite dispatchTouchEvent (MotionEvent e...

Android Custom TextView

Have you ever tried to add custom behavior to in-build Android Text View or create custom attributes? If yes, this article is going to help you. Here we'll create Single Custom TextView with support for custom attributes to display First and Last Name in different font and colors. During this process we'll learn following topics- 1. How to override default Views in Android 2. How to define custom Layout Attributes in Android So, Let's get started... Following sections explains necessary changes required in Java code and XML layout files. Create Custom Text View (MyTextView.java) 1. Override Android's default TextView   2. Implement Constructors. If you want custom attributes, override Constructor having Attributes in argument. 3. Override onMeasure(): Calculate required width and height, based on Text Size and selected Font. Once calculation is complete, set updated measure using setMeasuredDimension (reqWidth, reqHeight) Note: It’s really important to define the corr...

Google SpreadSheet Library for Android

You might have already tried using Google's GData Lib to access SpreadSheet from Android, and after few hours of try, you start Google for any alternate solution. I have also spent number of hours without any solution. So, I have developed SpreadSheet client Lib [ works on Android :-) ] and ideally work on any Java platform- http://code.google.com/p/google-spreadsheet-lib-android/ Latest version: 2.1 (Added support for List Feed. Please visit above link to get more info.) Supported Features: 1. Create/Delete Spreadsheet 2. List all stored Spreadsheets 3. Add/Delete WorkSheet into/from a given SpreadSheet 4. List all Worksheets of a given Spreadsheet 5. Add Records into WorkSheet/SpreadSheet (It supports Table based record handling) 6. Retrieve Record from WorkSheet/SpreadSheet ( Structured Query support) 7. Retrieve Record as List Feed from Worksheet 8. Update/Delete Records 9. Share ShreadSheet with user/group/domain. 10. Conditional data retrieval- ...

Android Fragment

Fragment is being hanging out since Andriod 3.0, but with the release of 4.0, it has become an obvious choice for Android Application development for both Tabs and Smart phones. Few people think, fragment is a " Superman " which can add any kind of UI layout/style/decoration. But that is not true, rather than being an UI layout or decoration enhancer, Fragment is a very important concept to manage segments of your UI component code base . Prior to Fragment, developers were able manage UI flow only at the Activity level. All UI components were Views (mentioned in XML layout and part of Activity) and there was no way to manage these components separately. As a result all view management code were in a single file i.e. Activity class. With fragment approach, we can now remove View management code from Activity and place them in their respective Java classes. So, a pretty neat approach for code management. Here I'll explain various concepts of Fragment with an example appli...

HashMap Internal

I always wanted to implement the logic behind the famous data structure of Java , HashMap and here it comes. Though it’s not the complete implementation considering all optimization scenarios, but it will highlight the basic algorithm behind the HashMap . So let’s start, this implementation will use my LinkedList implementation (Reason: for this implementation I thought to write everything from the scratch apart from primitive data types. Sounds weird? May be ;-) ). You may refer my earlier post on LinkedList , as I’m going to use it. HashMap is a key-value pair data structure, where you retrieve value by passing key. To optimize the search of key, a concept of Bucket (an Array of Java Objects) has been introduced. This is used, so that if search hits this Bucket , corresponding value element is instantly retrieved, otherwise it iterates sequentially through the Linked List associated with each Bucket element. So you can say if all HashMap elements get fit into the Bucket, retrieving...

Accessing Yahoo Finance API

Since last few days I was wondering the right set of Web Service to read Country wise Stock Exchange index information . I found a bunch of scattered information, but no straight forward answer. It seems there are not many "reliable" and "flexible" options and Yahoo Finance is one of the top of this class. Though Yahoo Finance is very powerful, some how its very less documented and it seems Yahoo doesn't care much about this wonderful web service and expect Developers to do some kind of "hacking". The only online resource that I (and most of you as well ) found is one 3rd party web site- http://www.gummy-stuff.org/Yahoo-data.htm and it seems they know much more than what Yahoo dose..;-) Anyway let me continue and share my experience and information to help budding developer who wants to use Yahoo Finance Web Service in their Mobile, Web o r Desktop s olution. There are 2 set of APIs to access Yahoo Finance details- YQL based Web Service : Th...

Eclipse EGIT, Download Code, Attach Framework code & Debug

This article explains procedure to download Android source (few important Apps and Framework base code) using Eclipse EGit plugin and then attach framework code to debug important framework classes (e.g. Activity etc.). Install EGit Download Source from GIT Repository Attach Framework code Debug Download EGit Plug-in EGit is a GIT plugin for Eclipse which helps to mange GIT clone, Check-ins, Sync etc. from your Eclipse workspace. Eclipse (Version: 3.7.x) -> Help -> Install New Software -> "Add" - " http://download.eclipse.org/egit/updates ". Once the plug-in installation is successful, you'll find a new Eclipse View perspective- "Git Repository Exploring"    Download Android source To download code from Android GIT repository, we need to create "local Git clone". Each local clone is associated with Remote Clone URL.   https://android.googlesource.com/ lists Git Repository URLs for different sections of An...